Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
3 posters
Staffordshire bull terrier :: Staffordshire Bull Terrier Forums :: Staffordshire Bull Terrier Breed Specific Legislation (BSL)
Page 1 of 1
Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
In the country that I live in, it is clearly stated in the law, as the exception, that the SBT is NOT concerned by the dangerous dogs act.
If I drive 15 minutes into neighbouring country, regional BSLs all put SBT in the same basket as pit bulls, all mastiffs, AmStaff, rottweiler and the such with the “dangerous dog” label. This technically means that minimum requirements include that the dog must be kept on lead not exceeding 2m length and must be muzzled in any public place.
As the laws are regional, it’s very difficult to get a straight and clear answer as to what is expected and what consequences are. Friends tell me that you won’t be stopped if dog not muzzled but in the case of an accident (bite/attack) then all insurance cover falls and the owners have integral costs. Some internet sites speak of fines.
I have no intention of muzzling Nifty as, aside her not needing to be, I feel it encourages a dangerous dog label and sterotypical judgement which couldn’t be further from the truth.
So do I keep all my own country papers (including copy of the law) to argue my ignorance or do I avoid ever taking Nifty into this neighbouring country ?
If I drive 15 minutes into neighbouring country, regional BSLs all put SBT in the same basket as pit bulls, all mastiffs, AmStaff, rottweiler and the such with the “dangerous dog” label. This technically means that minimum requirements include that the dog must be kept on lead not exceeding 2m length and must be muzzled in any public place.
As the laws are regional, it’s very difficult to get a straight and clear answer as to what is expected and what consequences are. Friends tell me that you won’t be stopped if dog not muzzled but in the case of an accident (bite/attack) then all insurance cover falls and the owners have integral costs. Some internet sites speak of fines.
I have no intention of muzzling Nifty as, aside her not needing to be, I feel it encourages a dangerous dog label and sterotypical judgement which couldn’t be further from the truth.
So do I keep all my own country papers (including copy of the law) to argue my ignorance or do I avoid ever taking Nifty into this neighbouring country ?
Nifty staffy- Staffy-Bull-Terrier Admin
- Status :
Online Offline
Dogs Name(s) : Nifty + Opium Black + Tigress
Dog(s) Ages : 15/04/2017 + 25/09/2018 + 02/05/2022
Dog Gender(s) : Female
Join date : 2017-05-26
Support total : 310
Posts : 3017
Re: Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
Wow that's crazy! To be honest if it were me I'd just keep Nifty in you're own country. Just to avoid any potential issues with the law. I wouldn't want to put her in a dangerous situation with regards to BSL.
Mistys Mum- Staffy-Bull-Terrier Admin
- Status :
Online Offline
Age : 45
Location : Surrey
Relationship Status : Married
Dogs Name(s) : Misty
Dog(s) Ages : 16 months
Dog Gender(s) : Female
Join date : 2015-04-02
Support total : 523
Posts : 2679
Re: Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
No, Ambiguous country is where my OH comes from, and where I work
B
B
Nifty staffy- Staffy-Bull-Terrier Admin
- Status :
Online Offline
Dogs Name(s) : Nifty + Opium Black + Tigress
Dog(s) Ages : 15/04/2017 + 25/09/2018 + 02/05/2022
Dog Gender(s) : Female
Join date : 2017-05-26
Support total : 310
Posts : 3017
Re: Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
In the region I am regularly in (with or without Nifty)
“The wearing of the muzzle is compulsory for any dog which is or circulates in any public or private place accessible to the public, if this dog constitutes a potential danger for his master or for others because of his behavioral behavior and / or aggressive character, or his selection and / or training to bite or violent antecedents that he would have demonstrated, with the exception of the dog services recognized as being of public utility (police dog or research for example)”
So how far back in a staffy‘s ancestory must we go ??
“The wearing of the muzzle is compulsory for any dog which is or circulates in any public or private place accessible to the public, if this dog constitutes a potential danger for his master or for others because of his behavioral behavior and / or aggressive character, or his selection and / or training to bite or violent antecedents that he would have demonstrated, with the exception of the dog services recognized as being of public utility (police dog or research for example)”
So how far back in a staffy‘s ancestory must we go ??
Nifty staffy- Staffy-Bull-Terrier Admin
- Status :
Online Offline
Dogs Name(s) : Nifty + Opium Black + Tigress
Dog(s) Ages : 15/04/2017 + 25/09/2018 + 02/05/2022
Dog Gender(s) : Female
Join date : 2017-05-26
Support total : 310
Posts : 3017
Re: Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
I've just had to look that up - it's new isn't it?
My gut feeling is that I probably wouldn't take her without trying to find out how the local authorities are applying the law. Even if the consequences are less dire than the BSL laws here, it would be distressing for you to get scooped up in it all. Does anyone in your dog club have contacts over the border, for example?
I personally wouldn't rely on the ignorance card. Ignorance isn't an argument to a policeman who is having a bad day or who needs to fulfil his quota.
My gut feeling is that I probably wouldn't take her without trying to find out how the local authorities are applying the law. Even if the consequences are less dire than the BSL laws here, it would be distressing for you to get scooped up in it all. Does anyone in your dog club have contacts over the border, for example?
I personally wouldn't rely on the ignorance card. Ignorance isn't an argument to a policeman who is having a bad day or who needs to fulfil his quota.
Guest- Guest
Re: Travelling, border hopping and contradictory BSL
It's an old saying, but "In the law, ignorance is no excuse".
Never play on the ignorance side of things - you could fail badly!
I would avoid that country (is there a read on you won't say which one?), but I would also buy a muzzle, train her properly to accept it, and carry it in your car/bag. Then, if you're stopped, you can say you were just giving her a rest from it, and pop it on.
Never play on the ignorance side of things - you could fail badly!
I would avoid that country (is there a read on you won't say which one?), but I would also buy a muzzle, train her properly to accept it, and carry it in your car/bag. Then, if you're stopped, you can say you were just giving her a rest from it, and pop it on.
gillybrent- Staffy-Bull-Terrier VIP Member
- Status :
Online Offline
Age : 58
Location : Northants
Join date : 2014-03-21
Support total : 456
Posts : 2479
Similar topics
» Contradictory training between family members
» .....and they say Border Collies are intelligent!
» Attack of the border terrier!
» Hampshire/Berkshire border
» Travelling
» .....and they say Border Collies are intelligent!
» Attack of the border terrier!
» Hampshire/Berkshire border
» Travelling
Staffordshire bull terrier :: Staffordshire Bull Terrier Forums :: Staffordshire Bull Terrier Breed Specific Legislation (BSL)
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum