Commercial dog treats

I admit to giving treats easily during any training but I try to be careful in what I give.
Anything that is too gungy and smelly is avoided (smackos, for example )

I look for “more natural” recipes and like the Core Wellness treats.
A new one I’ve just tried are the Carnilove treats. They do smell a bit strong (because of the herbs/fruit/general ingredients in them) but they are a great size and the girls love them. They’re just big enough to crunch without swallowing whole but not so big as 3=the equivalent of a meal !
Worth a try